Should You Switch to Top Entry Litter Box? The Pros & Cons

The top entry cat litter box is gaining popularity among cat owners looking for a cleaner, more stylish solution to their pet's bathroom habits. Unlike traditional front-entry boxes, these designs require your cat to jump in from the top, often featuring a lid with holes to sift out litter as they exit. But is it the right choice for your feline friend?

In this article, we'll break down the good, the bad, and the messy realities of top entry litter boxes for cats. Whether you're dealing with a litter-kicking menace or just curious about upgrading your setup, let's see if this design is the right fit for you and your feline friend.

Part 1. What Is a Top Entry Cat Litter Box?

A top entry cat litter box is a fully enclosed litter box with an opening on the top, rather than on the side or front. This design encourages cats to jump in and out through the top, reducing mess and limiting access for curious dogs or small children.

Compared to traditional open pans or front-entry hooded boxes, the enclosed structure helps contain odors and prevents litter scatter (in theory). Many models are more compact, fitting neatly in corners. It is a privacy for shy cats, and the full coverage can make anxious cats feel more secure.

Common features include high walls, removable lids for cleaning, and textured tops to help dislodge litter from paws. Some even have built-in filters or carbon liners to tackle smells. But while the concept sounds great, it's not a perfect solution for every cat—let's dig into the real pros and cons.

Part 2. Pros of Using a Top Entry Litter Box

✅ Reduces Litter Tracking: One of the biggest advantages of a top entry litter box is that it keeps litter where it belongs—inside the box. When cats jump out, any excess litter stuck to their paws gets knocked off by the grated lid, meaning fewer stray granules across your floors. If you're tired of finding stray litter granules all over your floors, a top-entry box might be your savior.   

✅ Minimizes Odor: Since the litter is enclosed within the box, odors don't spread as easily as they do with open-top designs. While no litter box is completely smell-proof, a top entry model does a much better job of containing unpleasant scents, especially when paired with a high-quality clumping litter and regular cleaning.  

✅ Privacy for Cats: If your cat is easily startled or nervous, having a more secluded spot might make them feel more comfortable and secure while using the litter box. The hooded design gives them a sense of security, making bathroom breaks less stressful—especially in busy households.

✅ Prevents Dogs from Digging: Dogs with a taste for "kitty treats" will be foiled by the top-entry design. No more unsupervised digging or, worse, snacking (yes, it happens). If you have a nosy pup, this alone could make the switch worth it.  

✅ Multi-Cat Households: In homes with multiple cats, litter box conflicts can be a problem. Some dominant cats will guard or block access to a front-entry box, but with a top entry model, it's harder to monopolize. This setup can help reduce territorial disputes over litter box access.  

✅ Aesthetic Appeal: Top-entry models often look like storage bins or furniture, blending into your home decor. No more awkwardly placed plastic pans ruining your aesthetic. Many models come in stylish colors and designs, making them less of an eyesore compared to a standard open litter tray. 

Part 3. Cons of Using a Top Entry Litter Box

Not Suitable for All Cats: Senior cats, kittens, or those with arthritis may struggle to climb in and out. Jumping in and out can be challenging for these felines, so if you have an older or less agile cat, a front-entry or low-sided box might be a better choice.  

May Require Training: If your cat is used to a traditional open box, you might have to gradually introduce them to the new setup, which could take time and patience.  

Cleaning Difficulty: Because of the enclosed design, you'll need to reach down into the box to scoop, which might be inconvenient, especially if the opening isn't large. Plus, if your cat is a high-pee-er, those walls will need frequent wiping. Some designs are also awkward to carry when emptying.

Size Limitations: Large breeds (like Maine Coons) or overweight cats may find top-entry boxes too snug. If your cat has to crouch uncomfortably, they'll likely protest by finding a "better" spot (like your laundry basket).  

Part 4. Alternatives to Top Entry Litter Boxes: Meowant Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box

If the downsides of a top entry litter box seem like a dealbreaker, consider a self-cleaning litter box like the Meowant Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box. The self-cleaning litter box eliminates the need for daily scooping, making it a hassle-free option for busy pet owners. Unlike top entry boxes, it's accessible to cats of all ages and sizes due to its low 4.8-inch entry, making it perfect for kittens and senior cats alike.

Key Features That Outperform a Top Entry Box:

⭐ 100% Safe: Uses advanced sensors to ensure your cat's safety during operation.

⭐ Spacious & Easy Entry: At 57.6L, it fits even large cats, and the 4.8-inch low entry is perfect for seniors and kittens.

⭐ Low Noise (<40dB): Operates quietly, making it ideal for sensitive pets.

⭐ Healthy Monitoring: Tracks your cat's litter box habits for potential health concerns.

⭐ Odor Removal: Built-in technology helps keep unpleasant smells under control.

With these features, the Meowant Self-Cleaning Litter Box provides a superior experience for both cats and owners.

Final Verdict: Should You Switch?

Top-entry litter boxes can reduce tracking and odors, but they're not perfect, especially for older, disabled, or stubborn cats. If you want true convenience, a self-cleaning box like Meowant's eliminates all the drawbacks while adding smart features. But if you prefer simplicity and your cat adapts well, a top-entry box might suffice. Either way—know your cat's needs before deciding!